Does a Metal Roof Increase Home Value in Western NC?
If you’re considering metal roofing, return on investment probably factors into your decision. Beyond the practical benefits of durability and low maintenance, you may wonder: will this investment pay off when I sell?
The short answer for Western North Carolina homeowners: yes, metal roofing generally increases home value. The longer answer involves understanding how much, under what circumstances, and why buyers in our market respond positively to metal roofs.
What the Data Says
National Studies
Several industry studies have examined metal roofing’s impact on home value:
Remodeling Magazine Cost vs. Value Report: Metal roof replacement consistently shows recovery rates of 60-70% of project cost at sale. This is solid compared to many home improvements.
Metal Roofing Alliance Research: Their surveys found that 64% of homeowners who installed metal roofing believe it increased their home’s resale value.
Realtor.com Analysis: Metal roofing appears among the most desired features for home buyers, particularly in regions with severe weather.
What These Numbers Mean
A 60-70% “cost recovery” rate means if you spend $25,000 on a metal roof, it adds roughly $15,000-$17,500 to your home’s value at time of sale. You don’t get dollar-for-dollar return, but you get substantial value back while also enjoying the roof’s benefits during your ownership.
Compare this to some other improvements:
- Kitchen remodels: 40-60% recovery
- Bathroom additions: 50-60% recovery
- Deck additions: 65-75% recovery
Metal roofing holds its own against major home improvements for resale value.
Why Metal Roofing Adds Value
Buyers paying a premium for metal-roofed homes aren’t irrational. They’re responding to real advantages.
Remaining Useful Life
When a buyer evaluates a home, the roof’s condition matters significantly. A 15-year-old asphalt shingle roof has maybe 5-10 years remaining and represents a major upcoming expense.
A 15-year-old standing seam metal roof has 35-45 years remaining. The buyer inherits a roof that will likely outlast their mortgage without replacement.
This difference is worth real money. Buyers factor in the cost of upcoming roof replacement when making offers. A home with an aging shingle roof often sees offers reduced by $10,000-$20,000 or more.
Inspection Confidence
Home inspections frequently flag roof issues. Curling shingles, missing granules, flashing concerns, ventilation problems. These findings create negotiation points and buyer anxiety.
Metal roofs generally inspect well. Fewer identified concerns mean smoother transactions and less negotiation pressure on price.
Lower Ownership Costs
Educated buyers understand that metal roofing means:
- Lower energy bills (10-25% cooling savings)
- Potential insurance discounts (5-30%)
- Minimal maintenance costs
- No replacement during their ownership
These ongoing savings have present value. A buyer calculating total cost of ownership sees metal-roofed homes as more affordable long-term.
Weather Resilience
Western NC buyers remember major storms. They’ve seen neighbors dealing with shingle damage claims and insurance headaches. A roof rated for 140 mph winds and Class 4 hail resistance provides peace of mind that has market value.
The Western NC Market Context
National data provides a baseline, but local factors matter for WNC homeowners.
Mountain Weather Premium
Our region’s weather creates specific buyer preferences:
- Heavy rainfall (47+ inches annually in Asheville)
- Winter ice and snow
- Summer thunderstorms
- Occasional severe wind events
Buyers in WNC weigh weather resilience more heavily than buyers in milder climates. Metal’s performance advantages carry extra weight here.
Property Type Considerations
Metal roofing’s value impact varies by property type:
Mountain homes and cabins: Metal roofing is almost expected on mountain properties. It fits the aesthetic, handles the conditions, and commands no premium because buyers assume quality mountain homes have metal roofs.
Historic neighborhoods: In areas like Montford or Grove Park, metal roofing can add significant value if it’s the historically appropriate type. A standing seam roof that matches the home’s era signals quality restoration.
Suburban tract homes: Metal roofing on a typical subdivision home stands out. This can be positive (differentiation) or requires the right buyer (not everyone wants to be different). Value impact is less predictable.
Rural and agricultural properties: Metal roofing is the norm. Buyers expect it, and shingle roofs may actually draw scrutiny.
Price Point Considerations
Metal roofing’s value impact varies with home price:
Entry-level homes ($200,000-$350,000): Metal roofing represents a larger percentage of home value. Buyers at this price point may be less focused on premium features and more focused on purchase price. Value addition is positive but modest.
Mid-range homes ($350,000-$600,000): Sweet spot for metal roofing value addition. Buyers in this range evaluate quality features and are willing to pay for long-term value.
Luxury homes ($600,000+): Premium features are expected. Metal roofing (especially standing seam or copper) signals quality construction. Absence of a quality roof at this price point raises questions.
Quantifying the Value Increase
Based on national data adjusted for our regional market, here’s a realistic range for value increase from metal roofing:
| Home Price | Estimated Value Increase | Percentage Increase |
|---|---|---|
| $300,000 | $8,000 – $15,000 | 2.5-5% |
| $450,000 | $12,000 – $22,000 | 2.5-5% |
| $600,000 | $18,000 – $30,000 | 3-5% |
| $800,000+ | $24,000 – $48,000 | 3-6% |
These estimates assume quality installation of standing seam or premium metal shingles. Budget metal products may show lower value addition.
When Metal Roofing ROI Is Strongest
Long-Term Ownership Before Sale
If you install a metal roof and sell 3 years later, you recover some value but not much time benefit. If you install a metal roof, enjoy it for 20 years, then sell, you’ve received two decades of benefits plus resale value.
The ideal scenario: install metal roofing when you plan to stay at least 10 years, then capture remaining value at sale.
Quality Installation by Reputable Contractor
Buyers and inspectors can tell the difference between quality installation and cut-rate work. Premium metal roofing from a reputable contractor with warranty documentation commands more value than questionable work from unknown installers.
Documentation
Keep records of your metal roofing project:
- Contractor name and contact information
- Material specifications and warranties
- Permit and inspection documentation
- Maintenance records
This documentation reassures buyers and supports value claims during sale.
Market Conditions Favoring Energy Efficiency
When energy costs rise, energy-efficient features gain value. When insurance rates increase in storm-prone areas, weather-resistant features gain value. Current trends favor both.
When Metal Roofing ROI Is Weaker
Very Short Holding Period
If you’re selling within 1-3 years, metal roofing isn’t primarily a value investment. You won’t recapture enough of the cost to justify the expense purely on resale basis.
Budget Installation
A cheap metal roof installed poorly doesn’t command the same value premium as quality work. Buyers who recognize metal roofing’s value also recognize quality differences.
Mismatched Style
A sleek modern standing seam roof on a traditional Colonial might strike some buyers as incongruent. Style compatibility matters for maximizing value.
Markets Where Metal Is Uncommon
In some neighborhoods, metal roofing is unusual enough that buyers don’t know how to value it. This isn’t really a WNC issue (metal is well-accepted here), but it affects some markets.
The Buyer’s Perspective
Understanding what buyers think helps frame the value proposition.
What Buyers Like About Metal Roofing
From buyer surveys and agent feedback:
- “I won’t have to replace the roof”
- “It handles storms better”
- “It looks sharp/modern/substantial”
- “Lower maintenance”
- “Better for the environment”
What Some Buyers Wonder About
- “Is it loud in the rain?” (No, with proper installation)
- “Does it attract lightning?” (No, this is a myth)
- “Will my cell phone work?” (Yes, not affected)
- “Can I walk on it?” (Yes, carefully)
Educated buyers understand these aren’t real issues. Some buyers need reassurance.
What Buyers Don’t Like
A small percentage of buyers prefer traditional shingle appearance and may not value metal roofing premiums. This is relatively rare in WNC but exists.
Maximizing Value at Sale
When you eventually sell your metal-roofed home:
Highlight It in Marketing
Make sure listing photos show the roof. Include metal roofing in property descriptions. It’s a selling point worth featuring.
Provide Documentation
Give your agent copies of:
- Installation documentation and warranties
- Maintenance records
- Material specifications
This information goes to serious buyers and supports the value you’re asking.
Price Appropriately
Work with your agent to price the home reflecting the metal roof’s value. Comparables with shingle roofs aren’t direct matches. Your home offers more value and can command more price.
Address Inspector Questions
If the buyer’s inspector asks about the roof, having documentation ready demonstrates responsible ownership and prevents unfounded concerns.
The Bottom Line on Value
Metal roofing increases home value in Western North Carolina. Buyers recognize the longevity, durability, and lower ownership costs. You can reasonably expect to recover 60-70% of your metal roofing investment at sale while enjoying the benefits throughout your ownership.
The value equation is strongest when:
- You plan to own the home 10+ years before selling
- You choose quality materials and installation
- Your home’s style suits metal roofing
- You maintain documentation
Metal roofing isn’t primarily a “flip” investment, but it’s an excellent long-term value choice for homeowners who want to protect their property and capture some of that investment at sale.
Ready to Add Value to Your Home?
If you’re considering metal roofing for your Western NC home, we’re happy to discuss your specific situation and provide a detailed estimate. Call Secure Roofing at 828-888-ROOF or fill out our online form.
Related Articles:
- Metal Roofing Costs in Western NC
- Metal Roof vs. Shingle: 60-Year Cost Comparison
- Metal Roofing Services
- About Secure Roofing
Internal Links to Include:
- Link to cost pillar: /services/metal-roofing/metal-roofing-cost-western-nc/
- Link to metal roofing page: /services/metal-roofing/
- Link to contact: /contact/
- Link to about: /about-us/