How to Save Money on Metal Roofing Without Sacrificing Quality

Metal roofing costs more than shingles upfront. That’s reality. But there’s a range of what “more” means, and smart decisions can put you on the favorable end of that range without sacrificing the quality and longevity that make metal worth considering in the first place.

This guide covers practical strategies for reducing your metal roofing costs while still getting a roof that will protect your home for decades.

Understand Where the Money Goes

Before cutting costs, know what you’re paying for:

  • Materials (40-50%): Panels, underlayment, fasteners, trim, flashing
  • Labor (50-60%): Skilled installation, custom detail work
  • Overhead: Permits, insurance, disposal, profit margin

Some cost-saving strategies affect materials. Others affect labor. The best approach depends on your specific project.

Strategy 1: Choose the Right Metal Roofing Type

Not every project needs the most expensive option. Match the roofing type to your actual needs.

Standing Seam ($9-$16/sq ft)

Best for: Primary residences, long-term ownership, maximum lifespan

Worth the premium when: You plan to stay 20+ years, you want minimal maintenance, appearance matters, you value the concealed fastener advantages

Metal Shingles ($7-$14/sq ft)

Best for: HOA communities, traditional home styles, mid-range budgets

Consider if: You like metal’s durability but prefer a traditional look, standing seam is overkill for your situation

Exposed Fastener Panels ($5-$10/sq ft)

Best for: Secondary structures, agricultural buildings, budget-conscious primary residences

Consider if: You’re comfortable with periodic fastener maintenance, the utilitarian look fits your property, budget is the primary constraint

Choosing exposed fastener panels over standing seam for an appropriate application saves 30-50% while still providing decades of service.

Strategy 2: Optimize Material Specifications

Within each roofing type, material choices affect price.

Panel Gauge

Residential standing seam typically uses 24-gauge or 26-gauge steel:

  • 24-gauge: Thicker, more rigid, better dent resistance, slightly more expensive
  • 26-gauge: Adequate for most residential applications, slightly less rigid

For most WNC homes, 26-gauge performs fine. Specifying 26-gauge instead of 24-gauge saves roughly $0.50-$1.00 per square foot.

When 24-gauge is worth it: Extremely exposed locations, homes under heavy tree cover with falling debris risk, or when you simply want the extra margin.

Paint System

Premium paint systems (Kynar 500, Hylar 5000) cost more but offer:

  • 30-40 year fade warranties
  • Superior chalk and corrosion resistance
  • Better long-term appearance

Standard SMP coatings cost less but may show wear sooner.

Our recommendation: For a primary residence, the premium paint system is worth it. Over a 50-year roof life, the cost difference is negligible per year, and appearance matters.

For secondary structures or budget-critical projects, SMP coatings are acceptable.

Panel Width

Standing seam comes in different widths (commonly 12″, 16″, or 18″):

  • Wider panels = fewer seams = slightly faster installation = slight cost savings
  • Narrower panels = more refined appearance on smaller or historic homes

Unless aesthetics specifically call for narrow panels, wider panels offer mild savings.

Strategy 3: Simplify When Possible

Roof complexity drives cost. Every valley, dormer, skylight, and transition requires custom work.

What You Can Control

Chimney removal: If you have an unused chimney (decorative or from a retired heating system), removing it eliminates a complex flashing detail. Discuss whether this makes sense for your home.

Skylight decisions: Skylights require careful flashing work. If you have older skylights due for replacement anyway, this is the time. If you’re adding new skylights, factor in the flashing cost.

Penetration consolidation: Multiple plumbing vents might be combinable into fewer penetrations. Ask your roofer if opportunities exist.

What You Can’t Control

Your roof’s fundamental geometry is what it is. A complex hip roof with dormers costs more than a simple gable regardless of material. Accept this as a fixed factor.

Strategy 4: Consider Roof-Over Installation

In some situations, metal roofing can install directly over existing shingles without a tear-off.

Requirements for Roof-Over

  • Single layer of existing shingles (not multiple layers)
  • Shingles in reasonable condition (not rotted or severely curled)
  • Solid roof deck underneath
  • Local code permits the approach

Savings Potential

Skipping tear-off saves:

  • Labor for shingle removal
  • Disposal fees (often $1-2 per square foot)

Typical savings: $2,000 – $4,000 on a 2,000 square foot roof

Trade-offs to Consider

  • Can’t inspect deck condition before covering it
  • Slightly uneven surface under metal (usually not visible)
  • Some consider tear-off the “cleaner” approach

We evaluate each project individually and recommend roof-over only when appropriate. Don’t let a contractor push roof-over if conditions don’t suit it just to win a lower bid.

Strategy 5: Time Your Project Wisely

Roofing demand varies seasonally, and timing can affect your options.

Peak Season (Spring and Fall)

  • Highest demand, busiest schedules
  • Less scheduling flexibility
  • No real disadvantage on price, but less negotiating leverage

Off-Peak (Winter and Mid-Summer)

  • Lower demand
  • More scheduling flexibility
  • Potentially more attention from contractors seeking work

Metal roofing can be installed year-round (unlike some materials with temperature restrictions). If your project isn’t urgent, scheduling during slower periods might provide minor advantages.

Avoid Storm-Chasing Season

After major storms, demand spikes and some less-reputable contractors appear. Prices don’t necessarily increase with established contractors, but availability tightens. If you can wait until the post-storm rush subsides, scheduling becomes easier.

Strategy 6: Get the Right Scope

Make sure you’re quoting what you actually need.

Common Over-Specifications

  • Premium trim packages when standard trim works fine
  • Extensive snow guards when your snow load is moderate
  • Premium underlayment everywhere when it’s only needed in specific areas

A good contractor helps you identify where premium options add value and where they’re unnecessary.

Common Under-Specifications

Watch for quotes that cut corners to appear competitive:

  • Inadequate underlayment
  • Minimal or missing ice and water shield
  • Cheap generic clips instead of manufacturer-specified components
  • Insufficient fastener/clip spacing

The lowest bid that omits necessary items isn’t actually the lowest cost. You pay later in repairs, reduced lifespan, or warranty issues.

Strategy 7: Bundle Projects When Practical

If you need other exterior work, combining projects can produce efficiencies.

Natural Combinations

Gutters: If your gutters need replacement, doing them with the roof avoids multiple mobilizations and allows better integration.

Siding repairs: If siding near the roofline needs attention, addressing it during roofing may be more efficient than a separate project later.

Solar preparation: If you’re considering solar panels, preparing the roof optimally during installation (seam placement, electrical conduit) saves versus retrofitting later.

Less Effective Bundling

Combining roofing with unrelated interior work or landscaping doesn’t produce roofing cost savings. Stick to projects with genuine overlap.

Strategy 8: Use Financing Strategically

If budget constrains your options, financing can help you get better value.

The Math on Financing

Scenario: Budget of $15,000 cash

Option A: Pay cash for exposed fastener metal roofing

  • 30-year lifespan
  • More maintenance
  • Earlier replacement

Option B: Finance standing seam metal roofing at $25,000 over 10 years

  • Monthly payment: ~$250-$300
  • 50-60 year lifespan
  • Less maintenance
  • No future replacement during ownership

Option B costs more in total interest, but delivers substantially more value and avoids future replacement costs and hassle.

Financing Options

Secure Roofing offers financing through Service Finance and Advancial:

  • 12 months same-as-cash (no interest if paid within 12 months)
  • Extended terms up to 144 months
  • Competitive rates

Home equity loans often offer even lower rates if you have equity available.

Strategy 9: Don’t Cheap Out on Installation

This deserves emphasis: installation quality matters more than almost anything else.

Why Cheap Labor Backfires

  • Improperly attached panels fail in wind
  • Poor flashing work causes leaks within years
  • Incorrect clip spacing leads to oil-canning and noise
  • Voided warranties from improper installation

The roof that was “$5,000 cheaper” but fails in 10 years wasn’t cheaper at all.

Signs of Quality Installation

  • Contractor has documented standing seam experience
  • Manufacturer certifications where applicable
  • Clear, detailed written scope
  • Verifiable insurance and licensing
  • Willingness to explain their methods

Pay for quality installation. Save money on materials and timing, not labor skill.

Strategy 10: Consider Long-Term Value

Sometimes the “expensive” choice is actually the cheapest.

Example: Saving $3,000 Upfront

Scenario: Choose 26-gauge panels with SMP coating ($22,000) instead of 24-gauge with Kynar 500 ($25,000)

Potential outcome: Roof still lasts 40-50 years, but paint fades more noticeably. You saved $3,000 and accept the cosmetic trade-off. Reasonable decision.

Example: Saving $8,000 Upfront

Scenario: Choose exposed fastener panels ($17,000) instead of standing seam ($25,000)

Potential outcome: Roof lasts 25-35 years instead of 50-60. Needs fastener maintenance. You’ll likely face one more roof replacement.

Is this “cheaper”? Only if you’re selling the home before the exposed fastener roof needs work. Otherwise, you probably spend more over your ownership period.

What Not to Do

Don’t Choose the Lowest Bidder Automatically

If one bid is 25% below the others, ask why. Maybe they found a genuine efficiency. More likely, they’re cutting materials, using inexperienced labor, or planning change orders.

Don’t Skip the Consultation

Online quotes and phone estimates can’t assess your specific roof. An in-person consultation identifies issues and opportunities that affect your real cost.

Don’t Delay Necessary Replacement

Waiting until your current roof fails completely often means:

  • Emergency pricing
  • Potential interior damage
  • Less time to evaluate options
  • Making decisions under pressure

Planning ahead lets you budget, evaluate contractors, and time the project optimally.

Don’t DIY Metal Roofing

This isn’t a realistic cost-saving strategy. Metal roofing requires:

  • Specialized equipment
  • Safety training and equipment
  • Knowledge of proper installation methods
  • Ability to fabricate custom flashing

DIY attempts typically result in inferior installations, voided warranties, and sometimes injuries. The “savings” become repair costs.

Getting Your Project Started

The best way to understand your real costs and options is a professional consultation. We’ll assess your specific roof, discuss your priorities, and provide detailed pricing for options that make sense for your situation.

Call 828-888-ROOF to schedule your free estimate. We serve Asheville, Hendersonville, Black Mountain, and communities throughout Western North Carolina.

Related Articles:

Internal Links to Include:

  • Link to cost pillar: /services/metal-roofing/metal-roofing-cost-western-nc/
  • Link to metal roofing page: /services/metal-roofing/
  • Link to financing: /financing/
  • Link to contact: /contact/